Anti-Tumor Necrosis Factor Treatment for Glomerulopathy: Case Report and Review of Literature
Background: Glomerulopathy involves damage to the glomerular filtration barrier for several reasons, resulting in idiopathic nephrotic syndrome (NS). Treatment options are limited and often include steroids with varying levels of response.
Case Presentation: A 7-year-old male with a history of NS at age 2 years that developed following a respiratory tract infection was found to have a heterozygous variant of uncertain significance in COL4A4 and TRPC6 genes. Biopsy findings included podocytopathy and changes in the basement membrane. Upon initial response to steroids, the patient was treated with a brief course of anakinra followed by adalimumab for > 2 years as steroid-sparing biological response modifiers. After a gradual taper, the patient remains in remission and has not received treatment in the last 12 months.
Conclusions: This case shows the complex nature of biologically predetermined cascading events in the emergence of glomerular disease with environmental triggers and genetic factors. Downregulation of somatic tissue-driven proinflammatory milieu originating from the constituents of the glomerular microenvironment can help in recovery from emerging podocytopathy. Blocking tumor necrosis factor-α early in the disease course, even temporarily, may allow time for the de novo regenerative process to prevail. Additional research is warranted to test this hypothesis and minimize steroid use.
Literature Review
There is a paucity of literature on applications of biological response modifiers for idiopathic NS and FSGS.23,24 Angeletti and colleagues reported that 3 patients with severe long-standing FSGS benefited from anakinra 4 mg/kg daily to reduce proteinuria and improve kidney function. All the patients had positive C3 staining in renal biopsy and treatment response, which supported the role of C3a in inducing podocyte injury through upregulated expression of IL-1 and IL-1R.23 Trachtman and colleagues reported on the phase II FONT trial that included 14 of 21 patients aged < 18 years with advanced FSGS who were treated with adalimumab 24 mg/m2, or ≤ 40 mg every other week.24 Although, during a 6-month period, none of the 7 patients met the endpoint of reduced proteinuria by ≥ 50%, and the authors suggested that careful patient selection may improve the treatment response in future trials.24
A recent study involving transcriptomics on renal tissue samples combined with available pathology (fibrosis), urinary markers, and clinical characteristics on 285 patients with MCD or FSGS from 3 different continents identified 3 distinct clusters. Patients with evidence of activated kidney TNF pathway (n = 72, aged > 18 years) were found to have poor clinical outcomes.25 The study identified 2 urine markers associated with the TNF pathway (ie, tissue inhibitor of metalloproteinases-1 and monocyte chemoattractant protein-1), which aligns with the preclinical findings previously mentioned.25
Conclusions
The patient’s condition in this case illustrates the complex nature of biologically predetermined cascading events in the emergence of glomerular disease upon environmental triggers under the influence of genetic factors.
Chronic kidney disease affects 7.7% of veterans annually, illustrating the need for new therapeutics.26 Based on our experience and literature review, upregulation of TNF-α is a root cause of glomerulopathy; further studies are warranted to evaluate the efficacy of anti-TNF biologic response modifiers for the treatment of these patients. Long-term postmarketing safety profile and steroid-sparing properties of adalimumab should allow inclusion of pediatric cases in future trials. Results may also contribute to identifying new predictive biomarkers related to the basement membrane when combined with precision nephrology to further advance patient selection and targeted treatment.25,27
Acknowledgments
The authors thank the patient’s mother for providing consent to allow publication of this case report.
