More Cardiologists Failing the Boards: Why and How to Fix?

Restoring Education, Board Passing Rates

“Having recently passed the ABIM cardiovascular board exam myself, my take-home message at this point is for current fellows-in-training to remain organized, track training milestones, and foresee any training shortcomings,” Dr. Kadado said. Adding that fellows, graduates and leadership should “identify deficiencies and work on overcoming them.”

The viewpoint authors suggested strategies that fellowship leadership can use. These include:

• Regularly assessing faculty emotional well-being and burnout to ensure that they are engaged in meaningful teaching activities
• Emphasizing in-person learning, meaningful participation in conferences, and faculty oversight
• Encouraging fellows to pursue “self-directed learning” during off-hours
• Developing and implementing checklists, competency-based models, curricula, and rotations to ensure that training milestones are being met
• Returning to in-person imaging interpretation for imaging modalities such as echocardiography, cardiac CT, and cardiac MRI
• Ensuring that fellows take the American College of Cardiology in-training examination
• Providing practice question banks so that fellows can assess their knowledge gaps

“This might also be an opportune time to assess the assessment,” Dr. Kuvin and colleagues noted. “There are likely alternative or additional approaches that could provide a more comprehensive, modern tool to gauge clinical competence in a supportive manner.”

They suggested that these tools could include assessment by simulation for interventional cardiology and electrophysiology, oral case reviews, objective structured clinical exams, and evaluations of nonclinical competencies such as professionalism and health equity.

Implications for the New Cardiology Board

While the ABIM cardiology board exam days may be numbered, board certification via some type of exam process is not going away.

The American College of Cardiology and four other US CV societies — the American Heart Association, the Heart Failure Society of America, the Heart Rhythm Society, and the Society for Cardiovascular Angiography & Interventions — formally announced in September that they have joined forces to propose a new professional certification board called the American Board of Cardiovascular Medicine (ABCVM). The application to the ABMS for a separate cardiology board is still ongoing and will take time.

An initial certification exam would still be required after fellowship training, but the maintenance of certification process would be completely restructured.

Preparing for the new board will likely be “largely the same” as for the ABIM board, Dr. Kadado said. “This includes access to practice question banks, faculty oversight, strong clinical exposure and practice, regular didactic sessions, and self-directed learning.”

“Passing the board exam is just one step in our ongoing journey as a cardiologist,” he added. “Our field is rapidly evolving, and continuous learning and adaptation are part of the very essence of being a healthcare professional.”

Dr. Kadado had no relevant relationships to disclose. Dr. Kuvin is an ACC trustee and has been heading up the working group to develop the ABCVM.

A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.