End-of-Life Palliative Care Rare for VA Patients With COPD

Though end-of-life care for veterans with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) in the US Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) has become more prevalent in recent years, a recent retrospective cohort study found that most patients do not receive palliative care or inpatient VA hospice over the past year of life, with rates lower than for other terminal illnesses. 

Among 332,770 decedents traced from 2010 through 2020, only 16.8% received either palliative or inpatient hospice care in the year before their death. The median time between their first palliative care appointment and death was 46 days, reported pulmonologist Natalia Smirnova, MD, assistant professor of medicine, Emory School of Medicine, Atlanta, et al in CHEST Pulmonary. 

A total of 15.9% of the decedents received inpatient hospice care from the VA. 

“These findings point to an opportunity to improve access to palliative care and hospice services for veterans with COPD, including earlier identification of need and stronger access pathways across care settings,” Smirnova told Federal Practitioner.

COPD Common Among Vets

An estimated 8%-19% of US veterans have COPD, higher than the estimated rate of 6% in adults from the general population. The condition is believed to be underdiagnosed in veterans. 

“Palliative care should be integrated early into routine care, when symptoms start,” Kathleen Lindell, PhD, RN, associate professor and chair, Palliative Care Health, School of Nursing, Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, explained in a Federal Practitioner interview. “COPD is a serious respiratory illness, and patients experience progressively debilitating dyspnea or shortness of breath, frequent hospitalizations. And they frequently experience high rates of anxiety and depression,” 

Lindell is familiar with the study findings but didn’t take part in the research. 

“Early palliative care,” she said, “addresses symptom management and advance care planning to reduce suffering and ensure what matters most to the patient as the disease progresses.”

Smirnova noted that “hospice is a related but distinct service for veterans with a terminal condition, generally when life expectancy is < 6 months and the veteran is no longer seeking treatment other than palliative care.”

The study analyzed electronic health records and patterns of palliative and hospice care in the year before death. The 332,770 patients were mostly male (98.1%) and White (81.0%). Many had comorbidities such as congestive heart failure (30.0%), depression (26.0%), coronary artery disease (25.5%), anxiety (13.4%), and lung cancer (12.1%).

Researchers found that palliative care was mostly (61.6% of encounters) delivered in the inpatient setting, where it occurred a median 30 days before death. In the outpatient setting, it began a median of 71 days before death. 

From 2010 through 2020, the prevalence of palliative care increased from 10.4% to 16.0%, and the prevalence of VA inpatient hospice care increased from 15.0% to 18.0%. Some veterans may have received hospice services in other settings; in-home hospice is common.

Who is More Likely to Receive Palliative Care?

Black patients (adjusted odds ratio [AOR], 1.21), Latino/Hispanic ethnicity (AOR, 1.22), patients with housing instability (AOR, 1.38) and who were underweight (AOR, 1.75) were linked to more palliative care use. Black patients were especially likely to get inpatient palliative care, a fact that “may, in part, be driven by increased care intensity at the end of life, as has been demonstrated in prior studies,” the authors noted.

Marriage (AOR, 0.88) was linked to less palliative care use, while patients with lung cancer were especially likely to receive it (AOR, 2.48). There were similar differences in use of hospice care apart from higher use for Black patients. 

Smirnova said the study was not designed to determine the causes of patterns in palliative care use. However, important factors appear to include hospitalization, comorbidities, and access to care at health care sites. (Usage rates were lower at rural centers and higher at more complex centers.)

COPD vs Other Terminal Diseases

“The modest increases in utilization of palliative care and VA inpatient hospice from 2010 to 2020 align with previous work [research] in inpatients with COPD and heart failure,” the researchers wrote, “possibly reflecting the effect of international professional society guidelines, increased acceptance of palliative care, improvements related to VA end-of-life care and life-sustaining treatment decisions initiatives, and increases in the specialist palliative care workforce.”

Still, there appears to be a major discrepancy regarding the use of palliative care for COPD within the VA compared with other diseases. A study of data from 2014 through 2017 found that for patients with several comorbidities—including COPD, heart failure, cancer, and dementia—inpatient palliative care was introduced a median of 58 days before death and outpatient care 160 days before death. 

“This suggests that veterans with COPD receive palliative care later than those with other serious illnesses,” the authors argued. 

Don’t Wait for the ‘Right Time’

Sarah Miller, PhD, RN, associate professor, and assistant dean, PhD Nursing Science Program, School of Nursing, Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, praised the study in an interview and noted that uncertainty about the “right time” to refer patients to palliative care could play a role in the findings. Miller is familiar with the study but did not participate in the research.

Lindell, the chair of Palliative Care Health, agreed.

“With COPD—a chronic, progressive disease—decline can be gradual, which makes it difficult to identify a clear transition point,” Lindell told Federal Practitioner. “This has contributed to many palliative referrals happening only when patients are clearly deteriorating or nearing the end of life. But palliative care should not be introduced reactively; it should be integrated early, alongside disease-directed treatment.”

For her part, Miller noted that “many veterans with COPD are navigating complex comorbidities and fragmented care across settings. Diseases like COPD don’t follow a predictable path, so referrals don’t always happen like they should.”

Moving forward, “if symptoms are present, early palliative care is appropriate,” Lindell said. These conversations should happen early and over time.

“The VA should prioritize early referral and access to palliative care for patients with COPD to provide the best care for these individuals.”

No study funding was reported. Smirnova discloses relationships with the CHEST Foundation and National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute. Other authors disclose relationships with various grantors. 

Miller discloses a relationship with AstraZeneca. Lindell discloses relationships with Boehringer Ingelheim and Heart & Lung: The Journal of Acute and Critical Care.