What’s new in transcranial magnetic stimulation

For now, experience indicates certain clinical factors may provide some guidance. Patients are usually better served by ECT if they:

• have depressive episodes of longer duration (eg, >3 years)
• have a high risk of suicide
• have psychotic or catatonic features associated with their depression
• have difficulty maintaining their physical well-being
• have bipolar depression.

Although existing evidence supports a possible benefit with TMS for bipolar depression (used in combination with a mood stabilizer), the lack of a definitive trial (precluding FDA clearance for this indication) and the lack of insurance coverage both limit the routine use of TMS for this indication.¹⁵

One potential advantage of TMS over ECT is a lower cost.¹³ Transcranial magnetic stimulation also may make it possible to achieve similar efficacy as ECT with fewer cognitive adverse effects when used in combination with ECT to reduce the number of acute ECT treatments required or as part of a maintenance strategy after a patient experiences an acute response to ECT.¹³

Magnetic seizure therapy (MST) vs ECT. An experimental treatment, MST uses a TMS device capable of producing more intense magnetic fields sufficient to induce a seizure.¹⁶ The advantage of MST over ECT-induced seizures is better control of intra-cerebral current path and density, thus avoiding deeper cortical areas associated with memory (eg, hippocampus) and minimizing cognitive adverse effects. As with ECT, however, anesthesia and muscle relaxation are required. Presently, MST remains investigational.

Other potential indications

In addition to MDD, TMS is also being studied as a potential treatment for other neuropsychiatric disorders.

Continue to: Obsessive-compulsive disorder