Midurethral slings
While often short-lived, the small risk of thigh pain with a transobturator sling makes me less likely to recommend this type of sling for a woman who is a marathon runner or competitive athlete. In her case, an analysis of possible complications includes the consideration that bladder perforation can be addressed relatively quickly in the operating room, while persistent thigh discomfort, though relatively rare, could be a debilitating problem.
Single-incision slings
There appears to be emerging evidence suggesting that some of the fixed and adjustable single-incision slings currently available may have efficacy similar to that of the slings that are now widely used.
A Cochrane Review presented at the 2014 AUGS-IUGA scientific meeting and published this summer concludes that there is not enough evidence on single-incision slings compared with retropubic or transobturator slings to allow reliable comparisons, and that additional, adequately powered, high-quality trials with longer-term follow-up are needed (Cochrane Database Sys. Rev. 2014;6:CD008709). However, research completed since the review offers additional data.
For instance, at the 2014 AUGS-IUGA scientific meeting this summer, an oral paper presentation highlighted findings of a randomized controlled trial that showed similar cure rates after surgery with the MiniArc, a fixed single-incision sling, and the Monarc transobturator sling (both by American Medical Systems) at 24 months. The study randomized 234 women to either sling and found no significant differences in subjective outcomes, objective outcomes, or results on various quality-of-life questionnaires.
As such studies are published and more evidence emerges, we will gain a clearer picture of how the newer single-incision slings compare to the well-tested retropubic and transobturator slings with respect to efficacy and safety.
Single-incision slings require only a small vaginal incision and no exit points. Without abdominal or thigh incisions, these new procedures – intended for less severe SUI (no ISD) – may offer improved perioperative and postoperative patient comfort and a potentially decreased risk of surgical injury to the adductor muscles, as well as a decreased risk of vascular and nerve injury. Candidates for these slings may include those who are very athletic, those who are obese, and those with a history of prior retropubic or pelvic surgery.
Research appears to be progressing, but at this time we do not yet have level 1 evidence to support their routine use.
Dr. Sokol reported that he owns stock in Pelvalon, and is a clinical adviser to that company. He also is a national principal investigator for American Medical Systems, and the recipient of research grants from Acell and several other companies.
