Symptoms, Not Size, Drive More Fibroid Surgeries : Women cite heavy bleeding and desire for pregnancy as most common reasons for elective operations.


BETHESDA, MD. — Large fibroids appear to grow faster than smaller fibroids, but symptoms, rather than growth rate, spur women to surgery.

A preliminary analysis of data from 120 women in the Fibroid Growth Study suggests that large fibroids (greater than 50 cm3) and medium fibroids (7 to 50 cm3), showed a significantly greater increase in size over 1 year, compared with small fibroids (less than 7 cm3).

“Most women have fibroids, but there is a subset of women that are symptomatic,” Barbara J. Davis, Ph.D., said at an international conference on uterine leiomyoma research sponsored by the National Institutes of Health.

Data on the factors that cause fibroids to grow and become clinically symptomatic are limited. “Our hypothesis was that fibroids are heterogenous and that growing tumors will have different cellular and molecular characteristics than nongrowing tumors,” said Dr. Davis, formerly chief of the Laboratory of Women's Health at the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences and now a principal scientist at AstraZeneca.

She and her associates sought to compare leiomyoma growth over time as a function of the number and location of the tumors.

To describe relationships between growth, clinical symptoms, and outcome, the investigators studied women at high risk for hysterectomy or myectomy.

The study results also indicated that intramural fibroids appeared to grow more slowly than did submucosal fibroids, fibroid growth might depend on the accumulation of fibrous tissue, and race had no effect on growth rate.

The study, funded by the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences and the National Center on Minority Health and Health Disparities, included clinically symptomatic, premenopausal women with large uteri—the size of 12 weeks' gestation—who had tumors of at least 2 cm in diameter, confirmed by ultrasound at baseline. Approximately 48% of the women were black and 41% were white.

The women had MRIs at baseline, 3 months, 6 months, and 1 year. They also underwent physicals, completed extensive medical history forms, donated blood and urine, and participated in monthly questionnaires via a 20-minute phone interview.

Women who opted for surgery donated their fibroid tissues to the study investigators and had a presurgical MRI to map the tumors for the surgeon so they could be identified by type and location.

A total of 31 women had either a hysterectomy or myomectomy during the course of the study. The average age of the surgery patients was slightly younger than the overall average (37.8 years vs. 39 years).

Overall, 1,076 fibroid volumes were calculated, including data from 52 women who completed all four MRIs—16 women who had surgery and 36 women who did not have surgery. The investigators used a computer program to overlay MRI images at different times and determine the growth rates.

In this preliminary analysis growth rate, defined by a change in volume, was mostly a function of location and other factors.

“We were surprised that there were not significant differences in the rate of growth between women of different race or ethnicity,” Dr. Davis said. The difference in the prevalence of fibroids between blacks and whites appears not to be caused by tumors growing faster in blacks.

“We did find that size was a factor in determining rates of growth,” she noted. The investigators were surprised that large and medium fibroids grew at a faster rate than small ones. “We thought that small tumors would be the fast-growing ones, and we thought we might find some that shrank, but we didn't,” Dr. Davis said. In fact, all the fibroids grew to some extent.

Intramural fibroid growth was slower than that of subserosal fibroids. However, growth rates between intramural vs. submucosal and between submucosal vs. subserosal were not significantly different.

As for the impact of growth rates on clinical outcomes, there were no significant differences between patients who had surgery and those who did not. “That was a surprise to us,” Dr. Davis said. “We wondered why the women were going to surgery.”

The answer is their symptoms. Symptom severity scores related to bleeding in surgery patients were almost double those of nonsurgery patients. Similarly, there was a significant difference in reported pain before and after surgery among surgery patients, compared with pain scores of nonsurgery patients.

Although the clinical symptomology differed between women who chose surgery and those who did not, the fibroid growth rates appeared similar in both groups. Dr. Davis noted the investigators have yet to review the impact of number of tumors on outcome. The total number of fibroids per woman ranged from 1 to 11.

Next Article: