Treatment Program Targets 'Disruptive Physicians' : Reasons for program referral include anger, performance and compliance issues, sexual misconduct, and theft.


ARLINGTON, VA. — Can a surgeon who brings a gun to the operating room be trusted not to use it? That's an extreme example of the kinds of questions that psychiatrists must address when doctors are referred to them for evaluations.

“Disruptive physicians” are doctors whose behavior undermines their personal and professional effectiveness, Ronald Schouten, M.D., said at the annual conference of the Academy of Organizational and Occupational Psychiatry.

“We are talking about people who engage in problematic behavior that interferes with their relationships at work or at home and has a potential impact on patient care, productivity, and administrative functions,” said Dr. Schouten, director of the law and psychiatry service at Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston.

Dr. Schouten presented data from his experience with 82 cases of physicians who had been referred for disruptive behavior. The doctors studied were evaluated for Axis I disorders, but the primary problems proved to be disruptive or noncompliant behavior. The sample excluded disability cases.

Overall, 69 doctors were referred by Physicians' Health Services at their hospitals, 7 by their practices or facilities, 3 by attorneys, 2 by residency programs, and 1 by the medical board.

Surprisingly, 15 were internists and family practice physicians, compared with only 3 general surgeons. “We expected to see more surgical specialists,” since surgery is stereotypically considered to be a particularly stressful field, he said. The average age was 48 years, and most of the doctors (82%) were men. Six of the internal medicine physicians were cardiologists, making cardiology the most common subspecialty in the sample.

Anesthesia was the most common specialty, comprising 13 cases, followed by ob.gyn., with 12 cases. Four of the cases involved emergency medicine physicians, three involved neurologists, and two involved psychiatrists.

Displays of anger proved to be the most common reason for referrals. In 36 cases, doctors were referred because they had lashed out physically or verbally, or because they had spooked their colleagues with behaviors such as wearing a gun in the operating room.

An additional 19 cases involved performance and compliance issues, and 11 cases involved sexual misconduct by the doctors. Other problems included sexual harassment, suspicion of substance abuse, communication problems with staff or peers, theft, and antisocial behavior.

Dr. Schouten noted that in California, the state medical board investigates about 10,000 complaints about disruptive physicians per year. Typically, nearly 80% of these are closed after an initial inquiry, but 20% are investigated further.

In this review, which looked at 584 physicians who had been disciplined by a state medical board over a 30-month period, 75 or 12.8% were psychiatrists—although psychiatrists make up only 7.2% of the percentage of physicians in California, he said.

Diagnosing disruptive doctors involves a caveat, Dr. Schouten said. When physician referral programs send doctors for a psychiatric evaluation, they often are unable to keep physicians in a behavior improvement program without a diagnosis of an Axis I or II disorder.

“There is a bias in favor of finding something to write on the form,” Dr. Schouten said. As a result of that bias, the most common diagnosis in his sample was “personality disorder not otherwise specified,” for 37 doctors, followed by 15 cases of major depression. There were also 10 cases of substance abuse, 9 diagnoses involving personality traits, 7 cases of adjustment disorder, and 6 cases each of bipolar disorder and sleep disorder.

Other non-Axis I and II diagnoses included two cases of anxiety disorder, two cases of attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder, and one case of obsessive-compulsive disorder.

Complete medical screening is an important part of a fitness for work evaluation. Hypertension, found in six cases, was the most common medical problem in the group, followed by hypothyroidism in five cases, and sleep apnea in four. In addition, there were two cases of diabetes, two of obesity, and one case each of Lyme disease, colon cancer, and irritable bowel syndrome.

Among the postevaluation recommendations for these physicians were initiation or continuation of psychiatric treatment, including psychotherapy with a focus on gaining insight into the reasons for the bad behavior; anger management; cognitive-behavioral therapy; and random urine screens in cases of substance abuse. Dr. Schouten strongly recommended that physicians receive follow-up treatment from someone of the same cultural background if possible who is not a colleague, even if that means traveling out of town. Bringing in a business consultant may help a stressed solo practitioner.

The data on outcomes for doctors who have psychiatric referrals are soft, he admitted, but about 80% of physicians whom he has evaluated returned to work. About 9% went out on disability.


Next Article: