Concurrent Notalgia Paresthetica and Brachioradial Pruritus Associated With Cervical Degenerative Disc Disease
Notalgia paresthetica (NP) is a common, often refractory sensory neuropathic syndrome with the hallmark symptoms of localized pruritus and dysesthesia of the unilateral infrascapular region. Brachioradial pruritus (BRP) is similarly classified as a localized pruritus syndrome but of the upper extremities, typically one or both forearms. Notalgia paresthetica and BRP are both generally chronic, nonlethal, incurable conditions with intermittent remissions and exacerbation. Often described as dermatologic syndromes, both diseases are typically considered to be multifactorial in etiology with an uncertain etiology. However, recent literature suggests that it is highly probable that NP in many, if not nearly all cases, has an association with underlying cervical disease at the C5-C6 levels. This elucidation has resulted in a paradigm shift in evaluation and treatment of NP as cervical disease with referred skin manifestations to the mid back. Notalgia paresthetica and BRP may occur concurrently in the same patients. To determine possible underlying cervical spine disease, it is vital to examine the neck and consider radiographic studies of the spine. Collaborative multispecialty evaluation may be indicated in primary management of these two conditions. For cases of NP and BRP that are associated with cervical disease, the first-line therapy may include nondermatologic spinal treatments. Many cases of NP and BRP are most likely dermatologic signs of underlying degenerative spine, disc, and muscle disease.
Practice Points
- Assess the spine in patients with notalgia paresthetica (NP) and brachioradial pruritus (BRP). Cervical spinal disease, especially at the C5-C6 level, may be the root cause of BRP and/or NP.
- Consider a multimodality approach to treatment, including physical therapy, acupuncture, massage, and transcutaneous electronic nerve stimulation.
- Treat the neck (underlying cause) and expect the skin (cutaneous symptoms) to follow.
Comment
NP Presentation
Notalgia paresthetica is a common, albeit heavily unrecognized and underdiagnosed, sensory neuropathic syndrome of the back, classically of the unilateral infrascapular region. Notalg
The dermatologic condition may consist of other symptoms that include but are not limited to localized burning, pain, tenderness, hyperalgesia, or dysesthesia. Notalgia paresthetica typically is associated with a poorly confined tan or hyperpigmented patch in the symptomatic area, though the skin may have no visible findings in many early cases. Notalgia paresthetica tends to be a chronic condition with periodic remissions and exacerbations. It is generally not associated with other comorbidities and is not life threatening; however, it does frequently decrease quality of life, causing much discomfort and annoyance to the affected patients.
Treatment
Topical therapies for NP have generally failed and are considered difficult because of the out-of-reach affected location. There is no uniformly effective treatment of NP.
Pathogenesis
The etiologies for NP and BRP are evolving and remain to be fully elucidated. Although the exact etiology remains uncertain, there are several possible mechanisms that have been proposed for NP: (1) neuropathy from degenerative cervicothoracic disc disease or direct nerve impingement,1 and (2) localized increased sensory innervations of the affected skin areas.2
Differential and Workup
The differential diagnosis in NP may include allergic or irritant contact dermatitis, fixed drug eruption, dermatophytosis, neoplasm, lichen amyloidosis, arthropod reaction, lichenified skin reactions including lichen simplex chronicus, neurodermatitis, infection, and other hypersensitivity reaction.
It is important during the initial assessment of patients with NP and/or BRP to obtain a thorough history of osteoarthritis, neck trauma, motor vehicle accident(s), vertebral fracture, cervical neoplasm or malignancy, family history of NP or BRP, or cervical disc disease. Radiographs or MRIs of the cervical spine may aid in diagnosis and treatment, and perhaps more so if there is an absence of contributory medical history. Radiographic imaging also may be indicated if there is a positive family history of osteoarthritis or vertebral disc disease.
A full laboratory workup including complete blood cell count, chemistry panel including renal and liver functions, and other laboratory tests (eg, IgE levels) may be warranted if pruritus is generalized and persistent to exclude other causes. Proper management of NP and BRP may involve a multispecialty effort of dermatology with radiology; orthopedic surgery; neurosurgery; neurology; and adjunctive fields including acupuncture, massage, chiropractic, and physical therapy.
NP and BRB Overlap
Because NP and BRP often originate from varying degrees of cervical disease, particularly at the C5-C6 level, traditional topical therapies aimed at treating the affected skin of the mid back and forearms may be ineffectual or partially effective as basic emollients. Due to NP and BRP’s periodic spontaneous remissions and exacerbations, it may be reasonably difficult to accurately measure direct response to various therapies. Some topical therapies aimed at the mid back skin or forearms may appear partially effective from a placebo-type perspective.
Currently, uniformly effective treatment of NP and BRP include the following: (1) therapies aimed at the cervical spine at C5-C6, including TENS, cervical massage, physical therapy, and acupuncture; and (2) therapies targeting the underlying lowered pruritus threshold such as oral antihistamines and narrowband UVB. Although uniformly effective treatments in this space had been previously lacking, traditional therapeutic options for NP and BRP included capsaicin cream, eutectic mixture of local anesthetic cream, topical steroids, pramoxine cream, topical cooling, oral steroids, menthol creams, various commercially available topical mixtures of menthol and methyl salicylate, cordran tape, intralesional corticosteroid injections, botulinum toxin injections,3 oral antihistamines, hydroxyzine, doxepin, topiramate, carbamazepine, antidepressants, gabapentin, oxcarbazepine, topiramate, thalidomide,4 paravertebral local anesthetic block, cervical epidural injection, surgical resection of the rib, and many others. Some of the tried systemic therapies exert their effect through the spinal nerves and central nervous system, thereby supporting the neuropathic etiology of NP.
Cervical Disc Disease
Alai et al1 reported a 37-year-old with documented NP on the right side of the back with MRI findings of disc disease at C5-C6 and mild nerve impingement that strongly suggest the association of cervical degenerative disc disease and NP.
Savk and Savk5 reported that 7 of 10 patients with NP demonstrated normal neurological examination and standard electrodiagnostic results. All had skin histopathology compatible with postinflammatory hyperpigmentation. There were no amyloid deposits or other described pathology on pathologic examination of the skin. Seven of 10 cases confirmed radiographic changes in the vertebra corresponding to the dermatome of the cutaneous lesion.5
An earlier study by Springall et al6 evaluating the mechanism of NP studied whether the cutaneous symptoms were caused by alternations on the cutaneous innervation of the involved infrascapular area. They p
Histologic studies have shown cutaneous changes in a few cases including lichen amyloidosis that may be secondary to the localized chronic scratching and rubbing.7 Clinical observations in orthopedics have established a clear relationship between the upper thoracic and interscapular region and the lower cervical spine. Frequently, cervical disc disease presents as referred pain in the upper thoracic and interscapular area. Similarly, some tumors of the cervical medulla also have presented as interscapular pain.8
Some have speculated direct involvement and actual entrapment of the posterior rami of T2-T6 spinal nerves.9 However, there are referred symptoms from the cervical area directly to the interscapular back. Degenerative vertebral and disc changes corresponding to the affected dermatome may be observed in some cases. Radiographic imaging of cervical and thoracic spine will help to exclude disc disease and possible nerve compromise.8
With advances in radiography and availability of MRI, earlier detection and intervention of cervical disc disease is possible. Early recognition may promote timely intervention and treatment to prevent cervical spine disease progression. In addition to degenerative cervical discs, osteoarthritis, and cervical spine strain and muscle spasm, there may be neoplasms or other pathology of the cervical spine contributing to NP and BRP.
There is some thought that there may be a relationship between NP and BRP. The described association of many cases of BRP and cervical spine disease6 and description of these diseases as likely neuropathic/neurogenic pruritic conditions also support a probable association of these two conditions. In contrast, NP has classically been described as unilateral in distribution, while BRP may involve unilateral or bilateral dorsolateral forearms. Most recently, as seen in our case, there are increasing incidences of nonclassic presentations of both of these diseases that may involve additional skin areas and be a basis for diagnostic challenges to the clinician.
First-line therapies for NP and BRP with associated cervical spinal disease are currently evolving and may include nondermatologic and noninvasive treatments such as spinal manipulation, physical therapy, acupuncture, cervical soft collars, massage, cervical traction, cervical muscle strengthening and increased range on motion, oral nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory medications (eg, ibuprofen, celecoxib, ketorolac), and oral muscle relaxants (eg, carisoprodol, cyclobenzaprine, methocarbamol, metaxalone). Curren
Conclusion
Notalgia paresthetica and BRP may not be solely skin diseases but rather cutaneous signs of an underlying cervical spine disease. The striking association of NP with BRP we present as well as the degenerative and/or traumatic cervicothoracic spine disease suggests that early spinal nerve impingement or cervical muscle spasm may contribute to the pathogenesis of these skin symptoms. Additional studies are needed to further assess the relationship of NP and BRP as well as the association of each disease entity independently with cervical spine disease, as it is unknown if these are causal or coincidental findings. Although topical therapies may seemingly help decrease the localized symptoms in NP and BRP in some cases, systemic or broader-scope cervical spinal evaluation may be warranted to fully evaluate refractory cases. Cervical spinal imaging and treatment, particularly at C5-C6 levels, may be appropriate as primary or first-line therapy in many cases of NP and BRP. The paradigm shift in thinking will more likely than not be to treat the cervical spine and the skin will follow.
