Ob.Gyn News Turns 50

Early days of IVF marked by competition, innovation


Access, income, and age

The IVF pioneers agree broadly that access to IVF is nowhere near what it should be in the United States, where only 15 states mandate any insurance coverage for infertility.

“Our limited access to care is a crime,” Dr. Toner said. “People who, through no fault of their own, find themselves infertile are asked to write a check for $15,000 to get pregnant. That’s not fair.”

Dr. DeCherney called access “an ethical issue, because who gets IVF? People with higher incomes. And if IVF allows you to select better embryos – whatever that means – it gives that group another advantage.”

Dr. Toner warned that the push toward genetic testing of embryos, especially in the absence of known hereditary disease, could create new problems for the profession – not unlike in the early days of IVF, when the Jones Institute and other clinics were picketed over the specter of “test tube babies.”

“It’s one thing to say this embryo does not have the right number of chromosomes and couldn’t possibly be a child, so let’s not use it, but what about looking for traits? Sex selection? We have this privileged position in which the government does not really interfere in what we do, but to retain this status we need to stay within the bounds that our society accepts,” Dr. Toner said.

In recent years, IVF uptake has been high among women of advanced reproductive age, which poses its own set of challenges. Outcomes in older women using their own eggs become progressively poorer with age, though donor eggs drastically improve their chances, and egg freezing offers the possibility of preserving quality eggs for later pregnancies.

“We could make this situation better by promoting social freezing, doing more work for women early in their lives to get out their own eggs and store them,” Dr. Miller said. “But again, you still face the issue of access.”

Regardless of what technologies are available or become available in assisted reproduction, doctors and women alike need to be better educated on their options and chances early, with a clearer understanding of what happens as they age, Dr. Bustillo said.

“This is not to pressure them, but just so they understand that when they get to be 42 and are just thinking about reproducing, it’s not a major surprise when I tell them this could be a problem,” she said.

Throughout 2016, Ob.Gyn. News is celebrating its 50th anniversary with exclusive articles looking at the evolution of the specialty, including the history of contraception, changes in gynecologic surgery, and the transformation of the well-woman visit.


Next Article: