Adherence to Recommended Inpatient Hepatic Encephalopathy Workup
Hepatic encephalopathy (HE) is characterized by altered sensorium and is the most common indication for hospitalization among patients with cirrhosis. Liver societal guidelines for inpatient HE revolve around identification of potential precipitants. In this retrospective study, we aimed to determine adherence to societal guidelines for evaluation of HE in 78 inpatients. The adherence rate to societal recommended guidelines for workup of HE was low, with only 17 (22%) patients having complete diagnostic workup within 24 hours of admission. Notably, 23 (30%) patients were not subjected to blood culture analysis, 16 (21%) were missing urinalysis, and 15 (20%) were missing chest radiograph. In patients with ascites (N = 34), 26 (77%) did not have a diagnostic paracentesis to exclude spontaneous bacterial peritonitis. In contrast, serum ammonia determination, a laboratory test not endorsed by societal guidelines for workup of HE, was ordered in 74 (95%) patients. These findings underscore the limited adherence to societal guidelines in hospitalized patients with HE.
© 2019 Society of Hospital Medicine
Statistical Analysis
Continuous and categorical variables are reported as means (± standard deviation), median (interquartile range or IQR), or proportion (%) as appropriate. Across-group differences were compared using Student t-test for normally distributed continuous variables and Mann-Whitney U test for skewed data. Fisher’s exact test was used to compare proportion. HE evaluations were quantified by the number of patients with complete workup and by the number of patients with missing components of the workup. A nominal P value of less than .05 was considered statistically significant. All statistical analyses were performed using SPSS Statistics version 24.0 (IBM Corporation, Armonk, New York).
RESULTS
Cohort Characteristics
The baseline cohort demographics are listed in the Table. Of the 145 patients identified using diagnostic codes for cirrhosis, 78 subjects met the study criteria. The most common exclusion criteria included non-HE etiology of altered mental status (n = 37) and patients with readmissions for HE during the study period (n = 30). The mean age of the study cohort was 59.3 years, and the most common etiology of cirrhosis was hepatitis C (n = 41), alcohol induced (n = 14), and nonalcoholic steatohepatitis (n = 13).
Initial Diagnostic Evaluation
The major precipitants of HE in the study cohort were ineffective lactulose dosing (n = 43), infections (n = 25), and electrolyte disturbances/renal injury (n = 6). At the time of admission, 53 patients were on therapy for HE. Only 17 (22%) patients had complete diagnostic workup within 24 hours of hospital admission. The individual components of the complete workup are shown in the Figure. Notably, 23 (30%) patients were missing blood cultures, 16 (21%) were missing urinalysis, 15 (20%) were missing chest radiograph, and 34 (44%) were missing urine drug screening. Of the 34 patients with ascites on admission, only eight (23%) had diagnostic paracentesis performed on admission to rule out spontaneous bacterial peritonitis.
Serum Ammonia Testing
Serum ammonia testing was performed on 74 patients (94.9%), and no patient met the criteria for appropriate testing. Forty patients already had a known diagnosis of HE prior to index admission. Furthermore, 10 (14%) patients had serum ammonia testing repeated after admission without documentation in the EMR to justify repeat testing. Emergency Department (ED) physicians ordered ammonia testing in 57 cases (77%), internists ordered the testing in 11 cases (15%), and intensivists ordered the testing in two cases (3%). The patient’s charges for serum ammonia testing at the time of admission and for repeat testing were $19,092 and $2,580, respectively.
DISCUSSION
This study utilized HE in patients with decompensated cirrhosis as a framework to analyze adherence to societal guidelines. The adherence rate to AALSD/EASL recommended inpatient evaluation of HE is surprisingly low, and most patients are missing key essential elements of the diagnostic work up. While the diagnostic tests that are ordered as part of a panel are completed universally (renal function, electrolytes, and glucose testing), individual testing is less inclined to be ordered (blood cultures, urine culture/urinalysis, CXR, UDS) and procedural testing, such as diagnostic paracentesis, is often missed. This last finding is in line with published literature showing that 40% of patients admitted with ascites or HE did not have diagnostic paracentesis during hospital admission despite 24% reduction of inhospital mortality among patients undergoing the procedure.9
