Adherence to Recommended Inpatient Hepatic Encephalopathy Workup

Clinical guidelines are periodically released by medical societies with the overarching goal of improving deliverable medical care by standardizing disease management according to best available published literature and by reducing healthcare expenditure associated with unnecessary and superfluous testing.¹ Unfortunately, nonadherence to guidelines is common in clinical practice² and contributes to the rising cost of healthcare.³ Health resource utilization is particularly relevant in management of cirrhosis, a condition with an annual healthcare expenditure of $13 billion.⁴ Hepatic encephalopathy (HE), the most common complication of cirrhosis, is characterized by altered sensorium and is the leading indication for hospitalization among cirrhotics. The joint guidelines of the European Association for the Study of the Liver (EASL) and the American Association for the Study of Liver Diseases (AASLD) for diagnostic workup for HE recommend identification and treatment of potential precipitants.⁵ The guidelines also recommend against checking serum ammonia levels, which have not been shown to correlate with diagnosis or severity of HE.^6-8 Currently, limited data are available on practice patterns regarding guideline adherence and unnecessary serum ammonia testing for initial evaluation of HE in hospitals. To overcome this gap in knowledge, we conducted the present study to provide granular details regarding the diagnostic workup for hospitalized patients with HE.

This study adopted a retrospective design and recruited patients admitted to the Virginia Commonwealth University Medical Center between July 1, 2016 and July 1, 2017. The institutional review board approved the study, and the manuscript was reviewed and approved by all authors prior to submission. All chart reviews were performed by hepatologists with access to patients’ electronic medical record (EMR).

Patient Population

Patients were identified from the EMR system by using ICD-9 and ICD-10 codes for cirrhosis, hepatic encephalopathy, and altered mental status. All consecutive admissions with these diagnosis codes were considered for inclusion. Adult patients with cirrhosis resulting from any etiology of chronic liver diseases with primary reason for admission of HE were included. If patients were readmitted for HE during the study period, then only the data from index HE admission was included in the analysis and data from subsequent admissions were excluded. The other exclusion criteria included non-HE causes of confusion, acute liver failure, and those admitted with a preformulated plan (eg, direct hepatology clinic admission or outside hospital transfer). Patients who developed HE during their hospitalization where HE was not the indication for admission were also excluded. Finally, all patients admitted under the direct care of hepatology were excluded.

Diagnostic Workup

The recommendations of the AASLD and the EASL for workup for HE include obtaining detailed history and physical examination supplemented by diagnostic evaluation for potential HE precipitants including infections, electrolyte disturbances, dehydration, renal failure, glycemic disturbances, and toxin ingestion (eg, alcohol, illicit drugs).⁵ Based on the guideline recommendation, this study defined a “complete workup” as including all of the following elements: infection evaluation (blood culture, urinalysis/urine culture, chest radiograph, diagnostic paracentesis in the presence of ascites), electrolyte/renal evaluation (serum sodium, potassium, creatinine, and glucose), and toxin evaluation (urine drug screening). Any HE admission that was missing elements from the aforementioned battery of tests was defined as “incomplete workup.” In patients admitted with decompensated cirrhosis, serum ammonia testing was considered inappropriate unless there was a nuanced explanation supporting its use documented within the EMR. The frequency and specialty of the physician ordering serum ammonia level tests were determined. The financial burden of unnecessary ammonia testing was estimated by assigning a laboratory charge ($258) for each patient.