Views of Primary Care Physicians Regarding the Promotion of Healthy Lifestyles and Weight Management Among Their Patients

There were no significant race-related differences in participating physicians views/beliefs, healthy lifestyle–related knowledge, and perceived barriers to helping patients engage in health promoting behaviors and weight management. There were no significant sex-related differences in these variables with the exception that women were more likely to respond that they did not know the BMI percentile range at which children or adolescents were considered to have a healthy weight (37.5% of women vs. 0% of men, P = 0.03). A similar percentage of men (66.7%) and women (64.7%) who chose among the 4 percentile range options (rather than endorsing “Don’t know”) chose an incorrect answer. Lastly, there were no significant self-reported BMI-related differences in participating physicians’ views/beliefs, healthy lifestyle–related knowledge, and perceived barriers to helping patients engage in health-promoting behaviors and weight management.

Discussion

Given the high percentage of adults in the United States who are overweight or obese and the associated health risks, it is paramount that primary care physicians advise their patients to manage their weight and adopt a health-promoting lifestyle. Research studies indicate that such advice is effective [18,19]. Furthermore, it has been found that most overweight and obese patients want more assistance with weight management than they are receiving from their primary care physicians [21]. This study thus explored primary care physicians’ knowledge, beliefs, and perceived barriers that may prevent them from providing such assistance. The primary care setting is the site where obesity disparity groups (eg, racial/ethnic minorities, groups with low household incomes) are most likely to receive care [22,23].

Most of the PCMH-affiliated physicians in this study agreed that they had the responsibility to promote weight-loss/management and healthy lifestyles among their patients. Consistent with prior research [9], the majority of the physicians in this study felt they were effective in their ability to counsel patients to eat a healthy diet and engage in physical activity. To illustrate, in a prior study [9], 77% of primary care providers thought that they could provide useful dieting tips to patients, and in this study, 80% believed they were effective in helping patients eat a healthy diet. However, despite this confidence in their ability to provide advice about healthy diets and physical activity, the providers in both this and in another prior study [25] were less confident in their ability to actually help patients lose weight. Only 64% of the providers in the present study felt they could be effective in assisting patients with losing weight or maintaining a healthy weight. Although this percentage is higher than the 44% of physicians found in a prior study [25] who felt confident in their ability to treat obesity, both studies clearly point to a need to decrease barriers that physicians face in helping clients lose weight.

A key finding of this study was the consensus among the participating physicians regarding what they perceived to be the common barriers to helping patients adhere to a health-promoting lifestyle. Consistent with past research [8,9], the 3 most common barriers cited by the participating physicians were that they did not have enough time, patients were not interested in improving their weight, and adequate referrals for diet, physical activity, and weight were lacking. Additional barriers endorsed included a lack of effective tools and information to give patients, and a fear of offending patients. Another barrier identified by the participating physicians is the perception that patients had difficulty in changing behaviors necessary for maintaining a healthier lifestyle.

When asked what would facilitate conversations with patients, the top 3 responses given were better tools to communicate diet, physical activity, or weight problems to patients or family members; better mechanisms to connect patients to specific referral sources; and better counseling tools to guide patients towards engagement in healthy lifestyles. Of note is the significant overlap between the perceived barriers and the needed facilitation tools. The clearest example of this overlap is that physicians noted a lack of adequate referral sources to be a barrier and that better mechanisms to connect patients to specific referral sources would facilitate their treatment of patients. Weight management referrals for patients in rural areas and for non-Hispanic black adults and Hispanic adults, among whom obesity is most prevalent in the United States [3,25], are particularly needed. Addressing this need is consistent with national calls to reduce/eliminate obesity and other disparities that plague the U.S. health care system. One promising avenue to facilitate weight management referrals is the development, evaluation, and wide dissemination of remote weight-loss support interventions, particularly in rural, racial/ethnic minority, and low-income communities. Indeed, several recent articles demonstrate the success of such weight management programs across diverse patient populations [27–29].

Many of the physicians who participated in the study (72%) endorsed lack of time as a significant barrier to discussing weight and weight-related behaviors with their patients. Therefore, finding time-efficient strategies to involve physicians in weight management interventions may prove particularly beneficial. One such evidence-based behavioral counseling framework—the 5As framework—has been endorsed by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services and the USPSTF for use with obese patients during a typical 20-minute visit [28].

The second highest-rated barrier, perceived patient lack of motivation, warrants additional discussion. Despite over half of the physicians surveyed citing this as a barrier, previous studies have shown that the majority of overweight patients believe they should lose weight and are interested in losing weight [21]. This study highlights a potential discrepancy between physicians’ perceptions of patients’ interest in weight-loss and their patients’ actual interest. It is possible that this discrepancy can be avoided by training physicians on how to be culturally sensitive when addressing weight with their patients. Moreover, such cultural sensitivity training may be of great use, given that 12% of physicians in this study were apprehensive about discussing weight with their patients due to fear of offending them. Such training typically involves teaching physicians how to talk with patients in ways that enable patients to feel comfortable, trusting, and respectful in patient-physician/provider interactions [29].

Two other findings pertaining to providers deserve mention. Specifically, 88% of physicians believed that effectively encouraging patients to adhere to a healthy lifestyle included personally engaging in health-promoting activities. However, of the physicians surveyed, 64% were overweight/obese. Given the high percentage of physicians in this study that were overweight/obese and these physicians’ belief that their personal engagement in health-promoting activities is important to encourage patient engagement in a healthy lifestyle, it seems that future efforts are needed to facilitate health-promoting behaviors among physicians—efforts that may in turn aid them in encouraging their patients to adhere to a healthy lifestyle.