Bringing the HPV vaccination rate into line with other adolescent immunizations

Missed opportunities for the HPV vaccine. One study showed that at least 86% of unvaccinated adolescents had missed opportunities to receive HPV vaccine.²⁹ A study of 14,588 adolescent girls from January 2010 through August 2015 showed that HPV vaccine was given at only 37.1% of visits in which MenACWY or Tdap vaccines were administered.³⁰ The rate of HPV vaccination was just 26% during well adolescent visits, and 41.8% during all other primary care visits.³⁰ Every adolescent health care visit—including visits for acute care, chronic care, follow-up, or office-based procedures—is an opportunity to review vaccination status.

Give vaccines concomitantly (simultaneously or same-day). ACIP counsels that minor illnesses, such as mild upper respiratory infections with or without low-grade fever, are not contraindications to routine vaccination.³⁰ Also, the safety of simultaneous vaccine administration, often a concern of both parents and health care providers, has been well established. Each vaccine’s immunogenicity and safety profile are maintained when given concomitantly with other vaccines, and fewer visits are needed to complete an adolescent’s vaccination status.^31,32

Immediately schedule follow up visits and use reminder/recall systems. Parents of adolescents who opt for HPV vaccination are not always aware of the timing of the 2- or 3-dose schedule and may not even be aware that more than 1 dose of vaccine is recommended.

In a study of 14,588 adolescent girls who had vaccinations at an office visit, only 37.1% also received the HPV vaccine.

A qualitative study of pediatric primary care providers and parents/guardians of adolescent patients showed that for HPV vaccination series completion, 65% of parents/guardians expected to be reminded of any needed doses, while 52% of the pediatric primary care providers relied on parents to schedule subsequent immunizations, and often the HPV series was not completed.³³ Higher completion rates of the HPV vaccination series were achieved when follow-up appointments were scheduled at checkout for the 2nd or 3rd vaccine dose after initiation of HPV vaccination.³³ The use of patient reminder/recall systems using telephone calls or mailings (phone usage is more effective than mailings) is also shown to improve vaccination completion rates.³⁴

Recommend HPV vaccination clearly and resolutely

In a cross-sectional survey of 800 parents of adolescents ages 9 to 14 years, HPV vaccine was deemed the least likely vaccine to have been “very strongly” recommended by their health care provider, compared with the strength of recommendations for influenza, Tdap, and MenACWY vaccines.³⁵ The strength of a health care provider’s recommendation to vaccinate is the single most influential factor in vaccine uptake.^10,36,37 Most family physicians self-report “always recommending standard pediatric vaccines”; however, only a minority are following ACIP recommendations.³⁸ A national study reported that only about two-thirds of parents who received HPV vaccine recommendations perceived a high level of health care provider endorsement.³⁹ The takeaway point: Give a clear, unambiguous, strong recommendation to vaccinate with HPV to prevent infection; cervical, oropharyngeal, and other cancers; and genital warts.

Continue to: Tell parents why the timing is important