Demographic Profile and Service-Connection Trends of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder and Traumatic Brain Injury in US Veterans Pre- and Post-9/11
Introduction: This study seeks to understand the demographic changes in the active-duty service member profile, both prior to and following September 11, 2001 (9/11). The study analyzed diagnosis of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and traumatic brain injury (TBI) and measures of severity of those diagnoses as recorded in service-connection ratings (percent disability).
Methods: A retrospective cohort-study of military veterans who received care at Veterans Health Administration medical centers between December 1998 and May 2014 was conducted based on clinical data recorded and stored within the Corporate Data Warehouse.
Results: A cohort of 1,339,937 veterans received an inpatient or outpatient diagnosis of PTSD and/or TBI. The cohort was divided into 4 service period groups and 3 diagnosis categories. The service periods included pre-9/11 (n = 1,030,806; 77%), post-9/11 (n = 204,083; 15%), overlap-9/11 (n = 89,953; 7%), and reentered post-9/11 (n = 15,095; 1%). The diagnosis categories included PTSD alone (n = 1,132,356; 85%), TBI alone (n = 100,789; 7%) and PTSD+TBI (n = 106,792; 8%). Results of the post-9/11 group revealed significant changes, including (1) increase of veterans with PTSD + TBI; (2) increase of female veterans with PTSD + TBI; and (3) increase of severity level of diagnosed PTSD/TBI as evidenced by higher service-connected disability pensions at younger age in the post-9/11 group. Additionally, data revealed unequal distribution of veterans with PTSD + TBI across geographic areas.
Conclusions: The veteran of the post-9/11 service period does not mirror the veteran of the pre-9/11 service period. Findings are valuable for policy making, allocation of resources, and for reconsidering the prevailing paradigm for treating veterans with PTSD and/or TBI.
Increases in PTSD Diagnosis
Increasing media awareness, mandatory battlefield concussion screening programs instituted by the US Department of Defense (DoD), and stressful conditions that exacerbate mild TBI (mTBI) may have all contributed to the increase in numbers of veterans seeking evaluations and being diagnosed with PTSD and/or TBI in the post-9/11 groups. Additionally, the 2007 National Defense Authorization Act requested the Secretary of Defense to develop a comprehensive, systematic approach for the identification, treatment, disposition, and documentation of TBI in combat and peacetime. By a conservative estimate, significant numbers of veterans will continue to be seen for mTBI at about 20,000 new cases per year.25-27
More frequent diagnosis of mTBI may have contributed to the increase in veterans diagnosed with PTSD+TBI in the post-9/11 groups. A recent study found that almost 44% of US Army infantry soldiers in Iraq did not lose consciousness but reported symptoms consistent with TBI.14 Compared with veterans of previous wars, veterans of the post-9/11 conflicts (OIF, OED, and OND) have experienced multiple, protracted deployments with infrequent breaks that can have a cumulative effect on the development of PTSD.8-10
The findings from the NVVRS study led to creation of specialized PTSD programs in the late 1980s. Since then, there has been an explosion of knowledge and awareness about PTSD, TBI, and the associated service-connected disability ratings and benefits, leading to an increased number of veterans seeking care for PTSD. For example, media coverage of the 50th anniversary of the D-day celebrations resulted in a surge of World War II veterans seeking treatment for PTSD and a surge of Vietnam veterans sought treatment for PTSD during the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.28 An increased number of veterans reporting PTSD symptoms prompted the DoD to increase screening for PTSD, and to encourage service members to seek treatment when appropriate.
The VA has instituted training programs for clinicians and psychologists to screen and provide care for PTSD. Beginning in 2007, the VA implemented mandatory TBI screening for all veterans who served in combat operations and separated from active-duty service after September 11, 2001. The 4-question screen identifies veterans who are at increased risk of TBI and who experience symptoms that may be related to specific event(s).29 A positive screen does not diagnose TBI but rather indicates a need for further evaluation, which may or may not be responsible for inflated reporting of TBI. Renewed research also has led providers to recognize and study PTSD resulting from noncombat trauma and moral injury. The possibility of delayed onset also drives up the number of veterans diagnosed with PTSD.5-7
Prevalence
A wide variability exists in the reported prevalence of PTSD among US war veterans with estimates ranging from 15% to 20% of veterans from recent conflicts3,20 and 10% to 30% of veterans from previous wars.3,19 These rates are higher than estimates from allied forces from other countries.19 Meta-analyses suggest that the prevalence of PTSD is 2% to 15% among Vietnam War veterans, 1% to 13% among first (pre-9/11) Gulf War veterans, 4% to 17% among OEF/OIF/OND veterans; these veterans have a lifetime prevalence of 6% to 31%.3,11,19,30-38 The prevalence of PTSD is 2 to 4 times higher among the US veterans19,39 when compared with that of civilians.40,41 According to one study, concomitant PTSD and TBI appears to be much higher in US war veterans (4%-17%) compared with United Kingdom Iraq War veterans (3%-6%).19
