Latest News

Body contouring tops list of cosmetic procedures with adverse event reports


 

FROM LASERS IN SURGERY AND MEDICINE

Cryolipolysis accounted for a majority of noninvasive cosmetic procedures associated with adverse events, according to an analysis of data from the Manufacturer and User Facility Device Experience (MAUDE).

The number of noninvasive body-contouring procedures performed in the United States increased by fivefold from 2011 to 2019, attributed in part to a combination of improved technology and new medical devices, as well as a “cosmetically savvy consumer base heavily influenced by social media,” wrote Young Lim, MD, PhD, of the department of dermatology, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, and coauthors.

However, premarket evaluations of many new medical devices fail to capture rare or delayed onset complications, and consumers and providers may not be fully aware of potential adverse events, they said. The MAUDE database was created by the Food and Drug Administration in 1991 to collect information on device-related deaths, serious injuries, or malfunctions based on reports from manufacturers, patients, and health care providers.

The researchers used the MAUDE database to identify and highlight adverse events associated with noninvasive body contouring technology in order to improve patient safety and satisfaction.

In their report, published in Lasers in Surgery and Medicine, they analyzed 723 medical device reports (MDRs) reported between 2015 and 2021: 660 for noninvasive body contouring, 55 for cellulite treatments, and 8 for muscle stimulation.

“Notably, of the 723 total MDRs between 2015 and 2021, 515 (71.2%) were reported in 2021, with the next highest reported being 64 in 2019 (8.8%),” the researchers wrote.

Overall, paradoxical hyperplasia (PAH) accounted for the majority of adverse reactions in the noninvasive body-contouring category (73.2%). In PAH, patients develop additional adipose tissue in areas treated with cryolipolysis. In this study, all reports of PAH as well as all 47 reported cases of abdominal hernias were attributed to the CoolSculpting device.

For cellulite treatments, the most common MDRs – 11 of 55 – were scars and keloids (20%). The Cellfina subcision technique accounted for 47% (26 of 55) of the MDRs in this category, including 9 of the scar and keloid cases.

Only eight of the MDRs analyzed were in the muscle stimulation category; of these, burns were the most common adverse event and accounted for three of the reports. The other reported AEs were two cases of pain and one report each of electrical shock, urticaria, and arrhythmia.

Patients are increasingly opting for noninvasive cosmetic procedures, but adverse events may be underreported despite the existence of databases such as MAUDE, the researchers wrote in their discussion.

“PAH, first reported in 2014 as an adverse sequelae of cryolipolysis, remains without known pathophysiology, though it proportionately affects men more than women,” they noted. The incidence of PAH varies widely, and the current treatment of choice is power-assisted liposuction, they said, although surgical abdominoplasty may be needed in severe cases.

The findings were limited by several factors including the reliance of the quality of submissions, the selection biases of the MAUDE database, and the potential for underreporting, the researchers noted.

However, “by cataloging the AEs of the growing noninvasive cosmetics market, the MAUDE can educate providers and inform patients to maximize safety and efficacy,” they said.

The size of the database and volume of reports provides a picture that likely reflects overall trends occurring in clinical practice, but in order to be effective, such databases require diligence on the part of manufacturers and clinicians to provide accurate, up-to-date information, the researchers concluded.

Pages

Recommended Reading

VIDEO: Dermatologists should embrace tissue adhesive
MDedge Emergency Medicine
Baux cut-points predict geriatric burn outcomes
MDedge Emergency Medicine
Hand washing and hand sanitizer on the skin and COVID-19 infection risk
MDedge Emergency Medicine
Guidance issued on COVID vaccine use in patients with dermal fillers
MDedge Emergency Medicine
Dermatologists skeptical of calamine lotion TikTok trend
MDedge Emergency Medicine