When to “Undiagnose” Asthma

During the 1-year follow-up period, 22 (10.8%) of the 203 patients who were initially judged to no longer have asthma had a positive bronchial challenge test; 16 had no symptoms and continued to do well without any asthma medications. Six (3%) presented with respiratory symptoms and resumed treatment with asthma medications, but only 1 (0.5%) required oral corticosteroid therapy.

WHAT’S NEW?

Asthma meds of no benefit for one-third of patients taking them

This study found that one-third of patients with asthma diagnosed in the past 5 years no longer had symptoms or spirometry results consistent with asthma and did well in the subsequent year. For those patients, asthma medications appear to have no benefit. The Global Institute for Asthma recommends stepping down treatment in adults with asthma that is well controlled for 3 months or more.⁵ Patients with objectively confirmed asthma diagnoses were more likely to still have asthma in this study—but more than 40% of patients who no longer had asthma had been objectively proven to have the disease at the time of diagnosis.

CAVEATS

High level of rigor; no randomized trial

This study used a very structured protocol for tapering patients off their medications, including multiple spirometry tests (most including methacholine challenges) and oversight by pulmonologists. It is unclear whether this level of rigor is necessary for weaning in other clinical settings.

Also, this study was not a randomized trial, which is the gold standard for withdrawal of therapy. However, a cohort study is adequate to assess diagnostic testing, and this could be considered a trial of “undiagnosing” asthma in adults. These results are consistent with those of another study of asthma disappearance in patients with and without obesity; in that study, about 30% of patients in either group no longer had a diagnosis of asthma.⁶

Using random dialing is likely to have broadened the pool of patients this study drew upon. Also, there is a possibility that the patients who were lost to follow-up in this study represented those who had worsening symptoms. Some patients with mild asthma may have a waxing and waning course; it is possible that the study period was not long enough to capture this. In this study, only about 3% of patients who had their medications stopped reported worsening of symptoms.

Continue to: CHALLENGES TO IMPLEMENTATION