CMS Proposes 30% Physician Pay Cut for 2012


The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services proposed that physician fees for 2012 would be reduced by 29.5%, even as the head of the agency vowed that the cuts would not occur. The proposed rule was released in the Federal Register July 1.

The reduction is required by the Sustainable Growth Rate (SGR) formula that was part of the Balanced Budget Act of 1997. But Dr. Donald M. Berwick, CMS administrator, said in a statement that the agency is hoping to find a way to avoid the statutory decrease.

“This payment cut would have serious consequences and we cannot and will not allow it to happen,” Dr. Berwick said. “We need a permanent SGR fix to solve this problem once and for all. That's why the president's budget and his fiscal framework call for averting these cuts and why we are determined to pass and implement a permanent and sustainable fix.”

Dr. Peter W. Carmel, president of the American Medical Association, said the reductions called for by the SGR formula are a constant threat to physicians' stability. “We are pleased that there is support from the administration and bi-partisan members of congress for permanent reform of this broken system, but agreement is not enough,” said Dr. Carmel, in a statement.

The AMA has been seeking a review and revision of the Medicare Economic Index (MEI), a measure of cost increases that affect physician practices. Dr. Carmel said that such a review was promised in the 2011 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule final rule, but the newly released proposed rule for 2012 shows it has not yet begun. “Revisions in the MEI could significantly reduce the legislative cost of permanent reform of the Medicare physician payment formula,” said Dr. Carmel.

The reductions could be deeper for some specialties – including cardiology – based on the impact of the Physician Practice Information Survey. The changes would reflect the third year of a 4-year transition to new practice expense relative value units. American College of Cardiology CEO Jack Lewin put this in perspective: “The 2010 payment rule was devastatingly bad. The 2011 rule was nowhere near as bad as that, and this one for 2012 is not full of apparent surprises. The 2012 rule has the third year of residual cuts that originated in 2010, but the impact next year averages out about negative 1%. The big impact would be the SGR cut of 29.5% if it were not waived – which it will be for a year at least I presume,” he wrote in his ACCinTouch blog.

And more payment changes may be looming. The CMS said in a statement that it is proposing to continue its efforts to identify what it calls “potentially misvalued codes.” As part of those efforts, it will be taking a look at all evaluation and management (E/M) codes to determine if they are undervalued. The agency also proposes to examine the highest non–E/M expenditure codes for each specialty to see if they are overvalued.

The agency will be looking at three cardiology codes that are potentially misvalued: data for cardiovascular stress test (93015), extracranial study (93880), and complete ECG (93000). According to ACC, these will be reviewed by the RUC for presentation to CMS before July 2012.

The agency said that the reviews will improve payment accuracy, in particular ensuring that primary care services are appropriately reimbursed. It's the first time the agency has looked across all specialties, according to the CMS.

Diagnostic imaging has been a target for Medicare, and it is again in this proposal. The agency wants to extend the multiple procedure payment reduction (MPPR) policy to the professional component of advanced imaging services, which includes CT) scans, MRI, and ultrasound. The agency said the reduction would affect about 100 types of services. It is also the first time that the CMS has taken aim at the professional component of these services. That component would be reduced by 50% for subsequent procedures furnished to the same patient, on the same day, in the same session, resulting in an estimated $200 million in savings, according to the CMS.

For the first time, the agency is proposing quality and cost measures to be used in setting incentive payments for physicians who provide higher quality and more efficient care. That lays the groundwork for 2015, when the Affordable Care Act requires the CMS to begin making payment adjustments for certain physicians and physician groups. The requirement goes into effect for all physicians in 2017. The agency is proposing to use 2013 as the initial performance year.


Recommended Reading

Perspective: Community First Choice Option
MDedge Cardiology
Medicare Part D Reduced Spending on Medical Care
MDedge Cardiology
Feds: Health Spending Growth Low in 2010
MDedge Cardiology
HHS Plans Revamp of Human Research Rules
MDedge Cardiology
IOM: Replace the 510(k) Device Process
MDedge Cardiology