Radiotherapeutic Care of Patients With Stage IV Lung Cancer with Thoracic Symptoms in the Veterans Health Administration
Background: Radiotherapy plays an important role in the palliation of lung cancer, which is the second most common cancer diagnosed in the Veterans Health Administration (VHA). The American Society for Radiation Oncology (ASTRO) developed evidenced-based treatment guidelines for the management of patients with metastatic lung cancer.
Methods: In May 2016, an electronic survey of 88 VHA radiation oncologists (ROs) was conducted to assess metastatic lung cancer management. Demographic information was obtained and 2 clinical scenarios were presented to glean opinions on dose/fractionation schemes preferred, preferences for/against concurrent chemotherapy, and use of endobronchial brachytherapy (EBB) and/or yttrium aluminum garnet (YAG) laser technology. Survey results were assessed for concordance with published ASTRO guidelines.
Results: The survey response rate was 61%, with 93% of the 40 VHA radiation departments represented. Among respondents, 96% were board certified, and 90% held academic appointments. 88% were familiar with ASTRO guidelines. Preferred fractionation schemes were 20 Gy in 5 fractions (69%) and 30 Gy in 10 fractions (22%). The vast majority (98%) did not recommend concurrent chemotherapy for palliation. In the setting of bronchial obstruction with lung collapse, about half (49%) recommended EBB or YAG lung reexpansion before external beam radiotherapy. A minority of respondents use stereotactic body radiotherapy or EBB for palliation.
Conclusion: Most respondents demonstrated up-to-date knowledge of current evidence-based treatment guidelines. We found no distinction in clinical decisions based on demographic profiles.
Methods
A survey instrument was generated by VHA National Palliative Radiotherapy Taskforce members. It was reviewed and approved for use by the VHA Patient Care Services office. In May of 2016, the online survey was sent to the 88 VHA ROs practicing at the 40 sites with onsite radiation facilities. The survey aimed to determine patterns of practice for palliation of thoracic symptoms secondary to lung cancer.
Demographic information obtained included years in practice, employment status, academic appointment, board certification, and familiarity with ASTRO lung cancer guidelines. Two clinical scenarios were presented to glean opinions on dose/fractionation schemes preferred, use of concurrent chemotherapy, and use of EBB and/or yttrium aluminum garnet (YAG) laser technology. Survey questions also assessed use of EBRT for palliation of hemoptysis, chest wall pain, and/or stridor as well as use of stereotactic body radiotherapy (SBRT) for palliation.
Survey results were assessed for concordance with published ASTRO guidelines. χ2 tests were run to test for associations between demographic factors such as academic appointment, years of practice, full time vs part time employment, and familiarity with ASTRO palliative lung cancer guidelines, with use of EBRT for palliation, dose and fractionation preference, use of concurrent chemotherapy, and strategy for management of endobronchial lesions.
Results
Of the 88 physicians surveyed, 54 responded for a response rate of 61%. Respondents represented 37 of the 40 (93%) VHA radiation oncology departments (Table 1). Among respondents, most were board certified (96%), held academic appointments (91%), and were full-time employees (85%). Forty-four percent of respondents were in practice for > 20 years, 19% for 11 to 20 years, 20% for 6 to 10 years, and 17% for < 6 years. A majority reported familiarity with the ASTRO guidelines (64%), while just 11% reported no familiarity with the guidelines.
When asked about use of SBRT for palliation of hemoptysis, stridor, and/or chest pain, the majority (87%) preferred conventional EBRT. Of the 13% who reported use of SBRT, most (11%) performed it onsite, with 2% of respondents referring offsite to non-VHA centers for the service. When asked about use of EBB for palliation, only 2% reported use of that procedure at their facilities, while 26% reported referral to non-VHA facilities for EBB. The remaining 72% of respondents favor use of conventional EBRT.
Respondents were presented with a case of a male patient aged 70 years who smoked and had widely metastatic NSCLC, a life expectancy of about 3 months, and 10/10 chest wall pain from direct tumor invasion. All respondents recommended palliative radiotherapy. The preferred fractionation was 20 Gray (Gy) in 5 fractions, which was recommended by 69% of respondents. The remainder recommended 30 Gy in 10 fractions (22%) or a single fraction of 10 Gy (9%). No respondent recommended the longer fractionation options of 60 Gy in 30 fractions, 45 Gy in 15 fractions, or 40 Gy in 20 fractions. The majority (98%) did not recommend concurrent chemotherapy.
When the above case was modified for an endobronchial lesion requiring palliation with associated lung collapse, rather than chest wall invasion, 20 respondents (38%) reported they would refer for EBB, and 20 respondents reported they would refer for YAG laser. As > 1 answer could be selected for this question, there were 12 respondents who selected both EBB and YAG laser; 8 selected only EBB, and 8 selected only YAG laser. Many respondents added comments about treating with EBRT, which had not been presented as an answer choice. Nearly half of respondents (49%) were amenable to referral for the use of EBB or YAG laser for lung reexpansion prior to radiotherapy. Three respondents mentioned referral for an endobronchial stent prior to palliative radiotherapy to address this question.
χ2 tests were used to evaluate for significant associations between demographic factors, such as number of years in practice, academic appointment, full-time vs part-time status, and familiarity with ASTRO guidelines with clinical management choices (Table 2). The χ2 analysis revealed that these demographic factors were not significantly associated with familiarity with ASTRO guidelines, offering SBRT for palliation, EBRT fractionation scheme preferred, use of concurrent chemotherapy, or use of EBB or YAG laser.
