Funding, Disparity Challenges Seen Ahead for HPV Vaccine


WASHINGTON — The challenge of paying for vaccinations will become even greater once the human papilloma virus vaccine becomes available in 2007.

At a meeting of the National Vaccine Advisory Committee, representatives from several organizations reported that there isn't enough money to go around and that states will have to make tough choices about funding for the HPV vaccine, which is scheduled to become a standard immunization for 11- to 12-year-old girls.

The evidence used by the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices to make vaccine recommendations includes economic factors as part of the public health perspective, said Dr. Lance Rodewald, director of the immunization services division at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. But the price of a vaccine cannot be a consideration for resolutions made by the Vaccines for Children (VFC) program. The key consideration in a VFC resolution simply is whether the vaccine is recommended for VFC-eligible children, he said.

Consequently, an ACIP recommendation raises the possibility for disparity, with VFC-eligible children receiving a vaccine because it is paid for, and children with private insurance not receiving the same vaccine because it is not paid for. Neither state-appropriated funds nor funds from Section 317 (a discretionary program within the Public Health Service Act that covers individuals whose insurance doesn't cover vaccines or who are not eligible for VFC funds) has kept up with VFC's need-based funding, Dr. Rodewald said.

What happens when the need outstrips the resources? “The programs are put in a tough spot,” he said. “The states will need to prioritize vaccinations, and we are looking to other groups to help resolve the financing dilemma.”

Dr. Poki Stewart Namkung, president of the National Association of County & City Health Officials, shared responses to a survey that solicited their members' concerns about implementing HPV vaccines. Key issues raised by the local health departments included how to vaccinate girls and young women who fall outside the bounds of public assistance given the limitations of the VFC program and Section 317.

States will receive VFC funding, but do not know what other funds to expect, said Claire Hannan, executive director of the Association of Immunization Managers (AIM). AIM members are involved in every aspect of vaccination, including distribution, purchasing, and provider and consumer education.

Uninsured individuals aged 9–18 years will be covered by VFC, and limited coverage for uninsured females aged 9–26 years may be available through Merck & Co.'s vaccine assistance program. Insured individuals are covered in theory, but AIM members are concerned that as new, expensive vaccines are added to the vaccine schedule, more insurance plans will not cover all the vaccines, Ms. Hannan said.

Next Article: