News

How Well Does the Third Dose of COVID-19 Vaccine Work?

Researchers compared 2 large groups of veterans to find out how well a third dose protected against documented infection.


 

How effective are the COVID-19 vaccines, third time around? Researchers compared 2 large groups of veterans to find out how well a third dose protected against documented infection, symptomatic COVID-19, and COVID-19–related hospitalization, intensive care unit (ICU) admission, and death.

The research, published in Nature, used electronic health records of 65,196 veterans who received BNT162b2 (Pfizer-BioNTech) and 65,196 who received mRNA-1273 (Moderna). They chose to study the 16 weeks between October 20, 2021 and February 8, 2022, which included both Delta- and Omicron-variant waves.

During the follow-up (median, 77 days), 2994 COVID-19 infections were documented, of which 200 were detected as symptomatic, 194 required hospitalization, and 52 required ICU admission. Twenty-two patients died.

In a previous head-to-head trial comparing breakthrough COVID-19 outcomes after the first doses of the 2 vaccines (given when the Alpha and Delta variants were predominant), the researchers had found a low risk of documented infection and severe outcomes, but lower for the Moderna vaccine. They note that few head-to-head comparisons have been made of third-dose effectiveness.

As expected, in this trial, the researchers found a “nearly identical” pattern for the risk of the 2 vaccine groups. Although the risks for all of the measured outcomes over 16 weeks were low for both vaccines ≤ 4% for documented infection and < 0.03% for death in each group—those veterans who received the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine had an excess of 45 documented infections and 11 hospitalizations per 10,000 persons, compared with the Moderna group. The Pfizer-BioNTech group also had a higher risk of documented infection over 9 weeks of follow-up, during which an Omicron-variant predominated.

Given the high effectiveness of a third dose of both vaccines, either vaccine is strongly recommended, the researchers conclude. They point to “evidence of clear and comparable benefits” for the most severe outcomes: The difference in estimated 16-week risk of death between the 2 groups was two-thousandths of 1 %.

They add that, while the differences in estimated risk for less severe outcomes between the 2 groups were small on the absolute scale, they may be meaningful when considering the population scale at which these vaccines are deployed.

Recommended Reading

Multiple myeloma diagnosed more via emergency care during COVID
Federal Practitioner
Study of beliefs about what causes cancer sparks debate
Federal Practitioner
Long COVID clinical trials may offer shortcut to new treatments
Federal Practitioner
New Omicron subvariant is ‘crazy infectious,’ COVID expert warns
Federal Practitioner
Long COVID comes into focus, showing older patients fare worse
Federal Practitioner