Treatment of Acetabular Fractures in Adolescents
Although the treatment of acetabular fractures in adults has evolved substantially, treatment of these injuries in adolescents remains primarily nonoperative.
We performed a retrospective review to evaluate outcomes of treatment of adolescent acetabular fractures. We identified 38 adolescent acetabular fractures (patient ages, 11-18 years), all treated by an experienced trauma surgeon. Open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) was performed in 37 cases, and 1 case was treated nonoperatively.
Mean follow-up was 38.2 months. All fractures healed. Reduction was anatomical in 30 cases, imperfect in 7. One patient had surgical secondary congruence, 1 had preoperative deep vein thrombosis, 1 developed a deep infection, and 2 had femoral head avascular necrosis and developed posttraumatic arthritis (both had hip dislocations). Of the 38 patients, 34 returned to full activity. At latest follow-up, 29 had no pain, and 6 had mild intermittent pain not limiting activity.
ORIF was found to be safe and to result in predictable union. We therefore advocate a more aggressive strategy. Given our low complication rate, we recommend nonoperative management only for stable, minimally displaced fractures (<1 mm). Unstable fractures, fractures with any hip subluxation, and fractures displaced more than 1 mm should be managed with ORIF.
As reported in adults, articular injury often is associated with secondary degenerative arthritis. This association is expected in adolescents as well. Given adolescents’ life expectancy subsequent to injury and surgery, any late posttraumatic arthritis will have a significant impact on quality of life over the long term, with increased duration compared with adults.
Minor complications (eg, meralgia paresthetica) resolved spontaneously. The most common complications were abductor weakness and heterotopic ossification. In only 4 cases was a secondary procedure for excision of the heterotopic bone required. Abductor weakness, more commonly associated with a Kocher-Langenbeck approach to the hip, resolved with therapy in almost all cases. Only 4 of our patients required removal of hardware from the acetabulum.
Although the majority of acetabular fractures resulted from high-energy trauma, 8 cases were sports-related. Six of these involved posterior wall fractures, suggesting the injury resulted from a fall on flexed knee and hip. This was not known to be a common mechanism of injury in this age group.3,7 An additional concern was how to size the posterior wall fragment when not ossified. At one center, preoperative magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) was effectively used to size the osteochondral posterior wall fragment as standard protocol for patients with posterior wall fractures in this age group—resulting in better decisions regarding the need for ORIF. At the other institution, preoperative MRI was not performed routinely for this subset of patients.
Thirty-four of our 38 patients returned to their normal activities. Of the other 4 patients, 1 was permanently disabled secondary to traumatic brain injury, 1 had other ipsilateral extremity injuries that limited his mobility, and 2 developed AVN of the femoral head. Both patients with AVN had hip dislocations. Four of the 6 patients who were symptomatic during activity sustained impaction injuries of the femoral head or posterior wall. This suggests that poorer outcomes may be associated with dislocation or with articular injuries—similar to what has been reported in the adult literature.
This study had several limitations. First, it was a retrospective case series, so there was no control group for comparison. Second, the relatively short follow-up did not allow evaluation of the incidence of degenerative arthritis secondary to articular injury, the symptoms of which may develop 1 to 2 decades after injury.13 This phenomenon was well described by Letournel and Judet21 in the adult population, and there is no reason to presume the adolescent population is any different. Third, our sample was small and unlikely to represent a uniform sampling of the general pediatric population. Fourth, it was not possible to draw detailed conclusions about the outcome of ORIF for a particular type of acetabular fracture. Fifth, we did not see as many of the associated visceral injuries that are so prevalent in the literature. This may reflect improvement in safety specifications for automobiles, or our group may not have had the most severe or high-energy injuries. Here our population sample may have skewed our results, leading to better than expected outcomes.
One last study limitation, a major one, was the age of our population, 11 to 18 years, which makes it difficult to extrapolate results to the entire pediatric population. On one hand, a more immature skeleton has a higher chance of remodeling and is more forgiving of deformities and small amounts of displacement. On the other hand, injury and premature triradiate cartilage fusion in a younger patient can lead to significant deformity and acetabular dysplasia.9 Whether ORIF of these fractures would alter the outcome of an injury to the triradiate cartilage is yet to be determined.
Conclusion
In agreement with earlier studies,10,11,15,18 the good outcomes in our series correlated with congruence of reduction. Outcome predictors such as dislocation, femoral head injury, and marginal impaction are similar to those described in the adult literature. Although our study did not have a nonoperative group for comparison, the favorable outcomes of ORIF of acetabular fractures suggest that a more aggressive approach to treatment should be considered. Given the added benefits of early, pain-free mobilization, we think that only stable, undisplaced fractures (<1 mm) should be managed nonoperatively. In the adolescent population, we recommend ORIF for optimal management of unstable acetabular fractures, fractures with any hip subluxation, and fractures displaced more than 1 mm.
