Commentary

The electronic medical record: Learning to swim

Author and Disclosure Information

 

References

This issue will disappear in less than one generation. Young people are remarkably able to multitask while typing. They are able to talk with their patients while typing and to look them in the eyes. And typing letter by letter will become obsolete as soon as voice-recognition software and ways to edit its output accurately are perfected. Many of us at Cleveland Clinic use a combination of templates, typing, and voice-recognition dictation, and find this to be effective.

When we tell our grandchildren that we used to type each individual letter on a page, they will be as amazed as we are to hear that cars used to be started with an external crank.

DOCTOR-DOCTOR COMMUNICATION IS ENHANCED

I agree that template notes written by physicians who cannot type very well can lack the substance and color found in a well-reported medical history and examination. But voice-recognition transcription can help flesh out key parts of the history, differential diagnosis, and management plan. Further, the note can be produced on the spot, the patient can check the note for accuracy, and the conclusions can be shared instantaneously with all involved caregivers. Doctor-doctor communication is thus enhanced.

EVERY REASON TO MOVE FORWARD

Dr. Hanlon is also concerned about EMRs and the potential for “billing creep” and outright fraud. But fraud is as old as billing. What is required is continued vigilance and system controls, which actually might be more effective in an EMR system than in a paper billing system. Integrity will be neither enhanced nor diminished by digitization, unfortunately.

In summary, while Dr. Hanlon sees reason to slow down the move to EMRs, I see every reason to move forward. The problems he describes are part of the growing pains of any new technology. He is right that we cannot move blindly, ignoring the challenges of this technology. But slowing down will only delay its benefits.

Next Article:

Vertebroplasty, evidence, and health care reform: What is quality care?

Related Articles