Conference Coverage

Vitamin D Deficiency/Breast Cancer Link Questioned

Major Finding: Serum vitamin D levels measured before diagnosis of breast cancer showed no significant association with breast cancer risk.

Data Source: A meta-analysis of 16 studies looking at the relationship between serum vitamin D levels and breast cancer risk.

Disclosures: Dr. Amir reported having no relevant financial conflicts.



SAN ANTONIO – A new meta-analysis challenges the notion that breast cancer risk is inversely related to serum vitamin D level.

The meta-analysis included 16 published studies deemed by investigators to have made the grade in terms of scientific rigor. In 10 studies, vitamin D was measured before diagnosis of breast cancer, while in the other 6 studies, blood samples were gathered for measurement of vitamin D only after the diagnosis.

When data from all 16 studies were pooled, lower vitamin D levels were associated with a significant 1.5-fold increased rate of breast cancer (P less than .001). So far so good for the theory that low vitamin D might be causally related to breast cancer, and by extension for the corollary that vitamin D supplementation might be an effective option for breast cancer prevention.

However, a major difficulty with this line of thinking arose when the two groups of studies were analyzed separately, Dr. Eitan Amir explained at the San Antonio Breast Cancer Symposium.

Indeed, only 1 of the 10 studies in which vitamin D was measured before diagnosis of breast cancer showed a significant relationship between low levels of vitamin D and subsequent increased likelihood of the malignancy.

In contrast, all six studies in which serum vitamin D was measured following diagnosis of breast cancer showed a significant inverse relationship. In the pooled analysis of these six studies, lower serum vitamin D was associated with a highly significant, 2.63-fold increased likelihood of breast cancer (P less than .001), according to Dr. Amir of the University of Toronto.

Breast cancer cells have been shown to express vitamin D catalytic enzymes that may interfere with accurate measurement of serum levels of the vitamin, added Dr. Amir.

Dr. Amir declared having no relevant financial interests.

   Comments ()

Recommended for You

News & Commentary

Quizzes from MD-IQ

Research Summaries from ClinicalEdge